Doctors That Accept Medicare in Cicero, NY
70 Medicare-enrolled clinicians · CMS data, refreshed 2026-06-26
These are 70 clinicians enrolled in Medicare and practicing in Cicero, grouped by specialty below. Being enrolled means they can bill Original Medicare for your care. Most also accept assignment — they take Medicare's approved amount as full payment, so you only owe your deductible and 20% coinsurance. Call first to confirm they're accepting new Medicare patients.
Providers in Cicero by Specialty
Family Medicine(6)
Joy Commisso, MD
Familycare Medical Group PC
8393 Elta Dr, Cicero13039
Paolo Pastore, MD
Familycare Medical Group PC
8393 Elta Dr, Cicero13039
Dennis Nave, MD
St Josephs Medical PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 1, Cicero13039
James Telonis, MD
St Josephs Medical PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 1, Cicero13039
Mary Geiss, DO
St Josephs Medical PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 1, Cicero13039
David Ouyang, MD
Zaki Badawy, MD PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 3, Cicero13039
Optometry(2)
Carolyn Cutre, OD
Carolyn A Cutre Od PLLC
8390 Elta Dr, Cicero13039
Julianne Shelton, OD
Carolyn A Cutre Od PLLC
8390 Elta Dr, Cicero13039
Podiatry(1)
Justin Beabes, DPM
Westside Podiatry Center Llp
6253 State Route 31, Cicero13039
Physical Therapist(7)
Cole Taylor, PT
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 6, Cicero13039
Sarah Coughlin
5849 E Circle Dr, Suite B, Cicero13039
Gary Morgan, PT
Morgan Physical Therapy PLLC
5740 S Bay Rd, Cicero13039
Nolan Rodriguez
Morgan Physical Therapy PLLC
5740 S Bay Rd, Cicero13039
Antoinette Eicholzer, PT
Onondaga Physical Therapy, LLC
6265 State Route 31, Cicero13039
Kayla Rutherford, PT
Onondaga Physical Therapy, LLC
6265 State Route 31, Cicero13039
Maryellen Tighe
Onondaga Physical Therapy, LLC
6265 State Route 31, Cicero13039
Physician Assistant(20)
Benjamin Colwell, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Caitlin Miller, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
David Keyes, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Erin Himes, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Jacob Mir, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Jason Presley, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Karina Volchkova, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Leith Ashkar, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Marlee Holleran, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Megan Mir, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Merrick Doody, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Natalie Zimmer
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Nina Magliocca, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Rusty Landon, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Scott Curran, PA
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Andrea Curtis, PA
Zaki Badawy, MD PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 3, Cicero13039
Glenn Gilberg, PA
Zaki Badawy, MD PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 3, Cicero13039
Mark Stever, PA
Zaki Badawy, MD PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 3, Cicero13039
Michelle Ederer, PA
Zaki Badawy, MD PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 3, Cicero13039
Rupinder Dhillon, PA
Zaki Badawy, MD PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 3, Cicero13039
Nurse Practitioner(17)
Cherice Stebbins, NP
D W Halliday MD Phd PLLC
6221 State Route 31, Suite 105, Cicero13039
Yoel Cruz, NP
New York General Medical Services PC
5460 Meltzer Ct, Cicero13039
Crystal Burrows, NP
On Care Family Health NP PLLC
6221 State Route 31, Suite 104, Cicero13039
Erin Dupree, NP
On Care Family Health NP PLLC
5972 State Route 31, Cicero13039
Kayla Nanna
On Care Family Health NP PLLC
6221 State Route 31, Suite 104, Cicero13039
Marissa Vartak, NP
On Care Family Health NP PLLC
5972 State Route 31, Cicero13039
Mona Smith, NP
On Care Family Health NP PLLC
5972 State Route 31, Cicero13039
Nicole Goult, NP
On Care Family Health NP PLLC
6221 State Route 31, Suite 104, Cicero13039
Alexandra Rubenstein, NP
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Kelly Kraus, NP
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Michael Dobrinski, NP
Wellnow Urgent Care, P.C.
8003 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Alexandra Cobb, NP
Zaki Badawy, MD PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 3, Cicero13039
Erina Myagkota, NP
Zaki Badawy, MD PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 3, Cicero13039
Karole Shafer, NP
Zaki Badawy, MD PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 3, Cicero13039
Maggie Towles
Zaki Badawy, MD PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 3, Cicero13039
Phitsamai Thatvihane, NP
Zaki Badawy, MD PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 3, Cicero13039
Stayce Huynh, NP
Zaki Badawy, MD PC
5586 Legionnaire Dr, Suite 3, Cicero13039
Chiropractic(5)
David Warchal JR., CH
6221 State Route 31, Suite 110b, Cicero13039
Erik Johnson, DC
8212 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Jeffrey Byrne, CH
6253 State Route 31, Cicero13039
Jeffrey Byrne, CH
6253 State Route 31, Cicero13039
Laura Carroll, DC
8212 Brewerton Rd, Cicero13039
Clinical Social Worker(1)
Shannon Galarneau, CSW
6084 Laramie Ln, Cicero13039
Emergency Medicine(1)
James Stevenson, MD
6170 Dawns Rdg, Cicero13039
Other Cities in New York
New to Medicare?
Frequently Asked Questions
Are these doctors in Cicero accepting new Medicare patients?
We can't say for sure — CMS's enrollment data confirms a provider is enrolled in Medicare, not whether their practice is currently open to new patients. Call first to confirm they're accepting new Medicare patients before you book.
What does "accepts Medicare assignment" mean?
It means the provider takes Medicare's approved amount as full payment for a covered service, so you only owe your normal deductible and 20% coinsurance — no extra charges. A provider marked "may accept assignment" can go either way, so ask when you call.
Will these doctors work with my Medicare Advantage plan?
Not necessarily. This directory is built from Medicare enrollment data, which applies to Original Medicare. If you have a Medicare Advantage plan, your plan's own network determines who's covered — check your plan's directory first, then confirm with the office directly.
Does Original Medicare cover dental care from these providers?
Original Medicare does not cover routine dental care like cleanings, fillings, or dentures. Some Medicare Advantage plans include dental benefits. See our guide on what Medicare does and doesn't cover for dental.
Provider data from the CMS Doctors and Clinicians National Downloadable File, refreshed 2026-06-26. Directory information only, not medical or insurance advice. View all Medicare doctors in New York →